The problem
Someone on Jobseeker’s Allowance in a Dublin City Council home works one 8-hour day at €14.15 an hour. They earn €113.20. Then:
- their welfare payment drops by €56.00,
- their council rent goes up by €10.30,
- and fares and lunch cost €9.00.
That leaves €37.90 for a full day’s work, or about €4.74 an hour. In a school-holiday week with paid childcare, it falls to €17.65. Without the childcare subsidy, they are €16.10 worse off for working.
Nobody pays tax at these earnings. The money goes on welfare cuts and rent increases, which together take 59% of every extra day’s pay. That is a higher rate than any high earner pays.
See the difference
The amount kept each week after welfare changes, extra council rent, €9 a day for fares and lunch, and any childcare cost. Childcare is school-age care at €6/hour with a €3.75/hour National Childcare Scheme subsidy: 4 hours a day in a school week, 9 hours in a holiday week.
How it works
- A €115 weekly allowance. The first €115 a week of earnings is ignored for welfare and council rent. It is linked to 8 hours at the minimum wage, so it rises when the minimum wage does.
- A 40% welfare taper. Above €115, the payment falls by 40c for each euro earned instead of 60c.
- Rent on what you actually gain. Council rent is set on the income left after the welfare reduction, not on gross pay.
- A 50% cap. Welfare cuts and extra rent together never take more than half of any extra euro earned.
- The same rules in every means test. HAP, RAS, Fuel Allowance, the medical card and the childcare scheme all ignore the first €115.
- Childcare for paid hours. Hours worked qualify for the full childcare subsidy, including in school holidays.
- A weekly earnings test. This replaces the rule that you must be unemployed 4 days out of 7, so there is no cliff on the fourth day.
What you keep each week
| Days worked | Current rules | First Day Free |
|---|---|---|
| 1 day | €37.90 | €104.20 |
| 2 days | €75.94 | €152.70 |
| 3 days | €113.91 | €200.30 |
| 4 days | Jobseeker’s Allowance stops | Payment keeps tapering |
Each extra day after the first is worth about €48 a week under the plan, so working more always pays.
Fair questions
Isn’t this unfair to low-paid workers who aren’t on welfare?
The plan should go alongside a higher USC exemption threshold, so that people already in low-paid work gain too. The aim is that every extra hour pays, for everyone.
What does it cost?
For someone who already works one day a week, the State gives up about €56 a week in welfare savings and the council gives up about €20 a week in rent. The return comes from people who aren’t working today and take up a day’s work. That is why we propose a pilot first.
Won’t employers just split jobs into one-day shifts?
Because the allowance is weekly, it doesn’t reward one-day jobs in particular. The pilot would also track how often claimants are hired for exactly one day, and the €115 level would be reviewed if that pattern grows.
How would it be introduced?
Through a two-year pilot in two council areas, measuring how many people take up work and stay in it, before any national rollout.
